September 19, 1650, before midnight Friday
Weather: with cool temperatures and a steady drizzle, with a moderate breeze
At the moment the bolts fly, the eyes disappear and there is splashing heard everywhere; Klaas's second shot is completely blind, as he cannot see a thing to shoot at (but being zero level and somewhat concerned, he shoots anyway).
[For the record, I should point out that I never did get a 2d6 roll for Klaas, to see if his morale is up to it - so I rolled myself]
That is it. Nothing else seems to happen. There is no advance from the creatures that the party is able to see. The party can detect no movement that disturbs the surface of the water, given that it is dark, and the continues to be a very light rain. The party is getting more damp, and Ahmet, who entered the water, is beginning to shiver.
I don't want to push the time that passes, for I don't want to invest the party, but no matter what you may do, I promise you that for five minutes, nothing happens.